Friendship with the World and the God Who Gives More Grace
On this page
Read James 4:1–12 before proceeding. Keep your Bible open throughout this session.
But He gives more grace.
James 4:6
The Heart of the Problem
After the portrait of the two wisdoms in the second half of chapter three, James now turns to a question he has clearly been working toward. Where do the quarrels come from? Where do the fights come from? Why is the congregation he writes to marked by internal conflict, by disputes, by friction among the very people who should be bound together in Christ? James does not let the question hang. He drives straight to the answer, and it is uncomfortable. The conflict comes from within. It comes from the passions at war within us.
This is one of the most searching passages in the letter. Over the course of twelve verses, James will name the root of congregational strife, diagnose our friendship with the world as spiritual adultery, call for submission and humility, and in the very center of it all, in a single startling sentence, he will deliver one of the most extravagant statements of grace in the entire New Testament. He gives more grace. More than what? More than our failing. More than our quarreling. More than our adultery. More than all of it. And in that single sentence the whole passage turns from diagnosis to Gospel, from Law to grace, from the rebuke we deserve to the mercy we do not.
This session will require some care. The diagnosis is severe. The language James uses (adulterous people, enmity with God, friendship with the world) is unsparing. If we handle only the Law portions of this passage, we will be left crushed under a burden we cannot bear. But if we handle only the grace portion, we will lose the weight that makes the grace so stunning. James holds the two together, and so must we. The path through this passage is the path of Law driving us to Gospel, and Gospel outshining the Law. Follow James where he leads, and you will find yourself, at the end, standing on ground that is somehow firmer than where you began.
What Causes Your Quarrels?
James opens the passage with a direct question. What causes quarrels and what causes fights among you? He is not asking rhetorically in the sense that he does not want an answer. He wants the answer clearly, because the answer is something his readers would rather not hear.
The conflicts in the congregation do not come from without. They do not come from the pressures of the surrounding culture, from the persecutions of the authorities, from the economic difficulties James has named earlier in the letter. All of these are real. But they are not the source of congregational strife. The source is internal. The conflicts come from your passions, your desires, which are at war within you.
This is a hard diagnosis because it places responsibility squarely on the shoulders of those who are fighting. It would be easier if James had said the problem was outside; then we could fix the outside or at least blame it. But James says the problem is within. Our fights in the fellowship hall come from disordered desires within our own hearts. Our disputes at elders’ meetings come from our own wanting-what-we-do-not-have. Our cold shoulders toward fellow members come from our own passions. The enemy is not primarily the other person. The enemy is the war within our own selves, which spills out into our relationships.
You Desire and Do Not Have
James continues with a startling string of descriptions. You desire and do not have, so you murder. You covet and cannot obtain, so you fight and quarrel. These are severe words, and they sound, at first, disproportionate. Most Christians in an ordinary congregation are not murderers. Why does James reach for such language?
For the same reason Jesus reached for it in the Sermon on the Mount, when He said that everyone who is angry with his brother is liable to judgment, and that whoever looks at a woman with lustful intent has already committed adultery with her in his heart. The trajectory of sin matters, not only its outward expression. The unmet desire that festers in the heart, the envy that wishes the other person would fail, the resentment that poisons our view of a fellow member — these are in the same spiritual family as the outward acts of violence they could grow into. James is not saying every Christian who has a heated exchange is a murderer in disguise. He is saying that the internal desires which produce our quarrels are of the same kind as the desires that, unchecked, produce far worse evils.
This is the doctrine of sin handled honestly. Not sin as a discrete set of bad actions to be avoided, but sin as a disposition of the heart that shapes everything that flows from us. We are not always adulterers in the outward act, but we are always capable of adultery because our hearts are still, in their fallen condition, capable of wanting what we should not want. We are not always murderers, but the capacity is there, and it expresses itself in our quarrels, our envies, our cold refusals of love. James is not flattering us. He is telling us what we are.
You Do Not Ask
Then James adds an observation that is both pastoral and surprising. You do not have, because you do not ask. The congregation is wanting things, struggling for things, warring over things, and they have not thought to ask God for them. They have assumed that if they want something, they must take it, or scheme for it, or manipulate others to give it to them. The simple path of asking the Father who gives generously has not occurred to them.
This is a rebuke of a particular kind. It is the rebuke of a Father who is not being trusted by His children. The quarrels of the congregation are partly a failure of prayer. Things we could have asked for and received, we instead fought over and lost. Relationships we could have brought to the Father, we instead tried to manage through our own strength and ruined. This is a thread that runs throughout the letter; James has already told his readers in chapter one that if any of them lacks wisdom, he should ask God, who gives generously. The readers have not asked. And their failure to ask is part of why they are quarreling.
You Ask Wrongly
But then James qualifies. It is not simply that the readers are not asking. When they do ask, they ask wrongly, in order to spend what they receive on their own passions. And at this point the diagnosis deepens. Some asking is worse than no asking at all, because it turns prayer itself into an instrument of the self. The prayer that says to God, give me what I want so I can use it for my own pleasure, is not the prayer of a child. It is the prayer of a manipulator trying to enlist God in a scheme the self has already committed to.
Be honest about how common this is. Christians pray for things constantly (for promotions, for reconciliations, for healings, for opportunities) and often the prayer is motivated by something less than love of God and love of neighbor. We want the promotion because we want more money, or status, or comfort. We want the reconciliation because we want to stop feeling uncomfortable, not because we genuinely desire the good of the other. We want the healing because sickness interrupts our plans, not because we trust God with the outcome either way. This does not mean such prayers are never answered; the Father is patient with weak prayers as He is patient with weak disciples. But James is telling us that the source of our quarreling is often that our very desires, even when we bring them to God, are misdirected. We are not asking as children of the Father. We are asking as consumers hoping to maximize our own satisfaction.
Friendship with the World
James now turns up the severity of the diagnosis to its highest pitch. You adulterous people! Do you not know that friendship with the world is enmity with God? Therefore whoever wishes to be a friend of the world makes himself an enemy of God.
The word adulterous is deliberately shocking. James is writing to Christians, baptized members of the covenant people of God, and he is calling them adulterers. But he is not accusing them of the outward act. He is accusing them of spiritual adultery, which is the Old Testament prophets’ standard charge against Israel when they went after other gods. To belong to the Lord and yet to give our affections elsewhere is to be an unfaithful spouse. It is to commit adultery in the spiritual sense. And James says that is what friendship with the world amounts to.
What Is the World?
The word world (kosmos) needs careful handling, because the New Testament uses it in multiple senses. God made the world and called it good. God loved the world enough to send His only Son. Christians are not called to hate the created order or to flee from ordinary human life. The world in those senses is not the problem.
But there is another sense of world in the New Testament: the world as the fallen human order in rebellion against God. The world’s values, priorities, idolatries, and systems. The world in this sense is not the lakes and the forests; it is the logic of self that shapes the fallen social order. It is the culture of wealth-as-identity, of status-as-meaning, of power-as-goal, of appetite-as-god. This is the world James has in mind when he calls friendship with it adultery.
To be a friend of this world is to take its measure of what matters as your own. It is to want what the world wants, to chase what the world chases, to fear what the world fears, to take pride in what the world takes pride in. The Christian, as James and Paul and John all teach, has been called out of this order into another. We still live in the world, geographically and vocationally. We are not to flee. But our hearts are to belong elsewhere. Our values, priorities, and fundamental allegiances are to be shaped by Christ and not by the fallen order around us. When the world’s values become our values, we have committed a kind of adultery against the Bridegroom to whom we belong.
The Hard Word
James does not soften what this means. Friendship with the world, he says, is enmity with God. Whoever wishes to be a friend of the world makes himself an enemy of God. This is not a statement of degrees, a sliding scale. It is a binary. You cannot be, at the deepest level of your allegiance, both a friend of the world and a friend of God. One of them must give way. The heart that pursues both will find itself divided, and eventually one will win.
This is the same teaching Jesus gave when He said no one can serve two masters. You will hate the one and love the other. This is the teaching John gave when he said if anyone loves the world, the love of the Father is not in him. The Scriptures speak with one voice on this point. There is no such thing as a comfortable dual citizenship between the kingdom of God and the fallen order of things. The attempt to hold both will, in the end, cost us the one that matters.
But He Gives More Grace
And now, in the middle of this severe diagnosis, James does something remarkable. He has just called his readers adulterers. He has just told them that their friendship with the world makes them enemies of God. Any reader of this passage, if he is honest, must recognize himself in the charge. The diagnosis fits. We have all been friends of the world in ways we would rather not admit. We have all had our loyalties divided.
And then James writes these words. But He gives more grace. Therefore it says, God opposes the proud but gives grace to the humble.
Stop and let those words land. But He gives more grace. The Greek word behind that but is a small one, yet here it carries great weight. It marks a sharp turn against everything that has come before. James has just laid out a devastating picture of human sin. He has pressed the diagnosis to its sharpest point. And then he turns. But. But He gives more grace. More than our failure. More than our adultery. More than our quarreling. More than our disordered desires. More than everything we have just had to face in ourselves.
This is one of the greatest Gospel sentences in the New Testament. It sits in the middle of the most severe passage in James’s letter, and it utterly transforms everything around it. Without this sentence, the passage would crush. With this sentence, the passage becomes an occasion to see more clearly the grace that is greater than all our sin.
Where the Sentence Comes From
James then supports the claim with a citation: God opposes the proud but gives grace to the humble. This is a line from Proverbs, and Peter quotes it also in his first letter. It is a deep theme in Scripture. God stands against the proud. God gives grace to the humble. The condition for receiving the grace that James has just announced is humility, the willingness to be honest about what we are, rather than defending ourselves or minimizing our sin. The proud, who insist on their own righteousness, find themselves opposed by the very God they think they are serving. The humble, who accept the diagnosis and come empty-handed, find themselves flooded with grace they could never have earned.
This is the Lutheran Gospel in miniature. We do not climb to God through our righteousness. We receive God’s grace as a gift, in the place of our emptiness and need. The proud hand is always a closed hand, and the closed hand cannot receive. The humble hand is always an open hand, and the open hand is what the Father fills. James is telling his readers that the way forward from their quarreling, their adultery, their enmity with God, is not to try harder but to humble themselves and receive the grace that is greater than all they have done.
More Grace Than What?
Consider the force of the word more. Grace that is more than what? More than the seriousness of our sin. We have just been called adulterers. More. We have just been told we are enemies of God. More. We have just been shown that our hearts harbor the passions that produce quarrels and even murder. More. Whatever the true extent of our sin is, and James has pressed it as severely as any New Testament writer, the grace of God in Christ is more.
This is the Gospel that sustains the Christian life. Not a grace that matches our sin point for point, as if the divine mercy were a careful accounting that offsets our debits with precise credits. A grace that exceeds. A grace that overflows. A grace that does not merely cover our failure but swallows it up in something larger. We have not measured the depths of God’s mercy if we think of it as just enough. It is more. More than we can imagine. More than we have dared hope. More than our sin, no matter how carefully we try to catalog what we are.
If you are reading this passage and feeling the weight of James’s diagnosis (and you should be, because any honest reader of this passage feels it) do not stop before you reach the but. The but is the most important word in the passage. But He gives more grace. All of what you have just seen is true about you. And then, against all of that, the grace of God in Christ is greater. Not equal. More.
The Shape of Humble Reception
James does not leave the call to humility as an abstract concept. He fills it out with a string of concrete exhortations that describe what it looks like to receive the grace he has just announced. Submit yourselves therefore to God. Resist the devil, and he will flee from you. Draw near to God, and He will draw near to you. Cleanse your hands, you sinners, and purify your hearts, you double-minded. Be wretched and mourn and weep. Let your laughter be turned to mourning and your joy to gloom. Humble yourselves before the Lord, and He will exalt you.
This is a remarkable sequence. It reads almost like a compact liturgy of repentance. Every verb matters. Together they paint the picture of what it looks like when a Christian, convicted by the diagnosis and confronted with the grace, turns his whole self toward the Father who gives more.
Submit, Resist, Draw Near
The first three verbs function together. Submit to God. Resist the devil. Draw near to God. These are not separable steps; they are aspects of one movement. To submit to God is to acknowledge His authority and place ourselves under it, the opposite of the friendship with the world that has made us enemies of God. To resist the devil is to refuse the seductions that would pull us back into that friendship. And to draw near to God is to close the distance that our sin has created, to approach Him not as strangers but as children who know their Father.
And the promise attached to drawing near is extraordinary. He will draw near to you. This is not a God who is reluctant, distant, hard to reach. This is a God who moves toward the one who moves toward Him. The space between us and the Father, which seemed so great under the diagnosis, is not one we close by our own first step. Even our drawing near is the work of the grace James has just announced, for no one comes to Christ unless the Father draws him. But the promise stands: the one whom grace has turned toward God finds God already there, more eager to receive us than we are to come.
Cleanse Your Hands, Purify Your Hearts
The next two verbs, cleanse and purify, recall the Old Testament imagery of ritual purification before approaching God. But James is not prescribing external rites. He is using the imagery to describe the inward reality. To cleanse the hands means to deal honestly with what we have done. To purify the heart means to deal honestly with what we have wanted. The double-minded person, a phrase James used back in chapter one, is the person whose heart is divided between God and the world. James is calling him to become single-minded, to let the divided loyalty resolve into wholehearted devotion.
And notice the address: you sinners, you double-minded. James does not flatter. He names what we are. This is the precondition of the healing he is describing. We must let the diagnosis stand before we can receive the grace. We cannot approach God claiming a righteousness we do not possess. We come as sinners, as the double-minded, asking for the grace that is more than our sin.
Be Wretched and Mourn
The next phrase is the most uncomfortable. Be wretched and mourn and weep. Let your laughter be turned to mourning and your joy to gloom. This sounds, on its face, like James is commending a general misery. But he is not. He is describing the specific posture of repentance.
The Christian who has seen his friendship with the world for what it is does not shrug it off with a joke. He does not minimize it, excuse it, or redefine it. He mourns it. He weeps over it. This is not a permanent posture; it is not the whole Christian life. The same James who calls his readers to mourn has told them, earlier, to count trials as joy, and he will end the letter with exhortations to prayer and song. But in the moment of facing our sin honestly, the right response is grief, not lightness. We weep because the sin we have just seen in ourselves is grievous. And the grief itself is part of the humility that receives the grace.
This is what confessional Lutherans have traditionally called contrition, a true sorrow for sin, not merely a regret for consequences. Contrition is not the payment for our sin; nothing we do pays for our sin. But contrition is the posture of the heart that is ready to receive forgiveness. The person who laughs off his sin is not yet ready to be forgiven, because he has not yet received the diagnosis. The person who mourns his sin is ready, because he has acknowledged what he is, and in that acknowledgment the door opens for the grace that is more.
Humble Yourselves, and He Will Exalt You
The sequence ends with a promise. Humble yourselves before the Lord, and He will exalt you. This echoes one of the most consistent themes in all of Scripture. God opposes the proud and gives grace to the humble. The humble are lifted up, and the proud are cast down. Mary sang it in the Magnificat. Jesus taught it in parable after parable. And James proclaims it here as the final word of his call to repentance.
The logic is profound. We cannot exalt ourselves. Every attempt to lift ourselves up only drives us further from God. But when we humble ourselves (when we come empty-handed, acknowledging what we are, asking for grace we do not deserve) the Lord Himself lifts us up. This is the Gospel pattern. The Father who opposed us in our pride now exalts us in our humility, not because our humility has earned anything, but because humility is the posture in which we can receive what only He can give.
Do Not Speak Evil Against One Another
James closes this section with a final exhortation that ties it to what he has been saying about the tongue and about the assembly. Do not speak evil against one another, brothers. The one who speaks against a brother or judges his brother, speaks evil against the Law and judges the Law. But if you judge the Law, you are not a doer of the Law but a judge.
This may seem like an abrupt turn, but it is not. James has just been calling his readers to humble themselves, to acknowledge their sinfulness, to receive grace. But there is one form of pride that particularly opposes this posture: the pride that takes the place of the Judge, that stands above the Law rather than under it, that speaks against others as if we were not ourselves in need of the very mercy we are reluctant to extend.
When we speak evil of a brother, when we pronounce judgment on a fellow member, when we set ourselves up as the arbiters of who is in and who is out, we have climbed into a seat that is not ours. The seat of the Judge belongs to the Lord. There is one Lawgiver and Judge, James says, He who is able to save and to destroy. But who are you to judge your neighbor?
This is the Christian’s proper posture. We stand under the Law, not above it. We are ourselves guilty, and only the mercy of God has kept us. From that position, the proper response to a fellow sinner is not judgment but the same mercy we have received. To judge our brother harshly is to contradict the Gospel we claim to believe. It is to act as if the grace that saved us is not the grace that saves him too.
This connects beautifully to what James said back in chapter two: mercy triumphs over judgment. The one who has received mercy does not become a judge of others. The one who understands his own need for grace extends grace to others. And the one who persists in judging others, James warns, reveals something troubling about himself: that he has not yet understood his own standing before the Law or his own need for the very grace he is withholding.
Gathering the Threads
The arc of this passage is one of the clearest demonstrations of Law and Gospel in the whole letter. James opens by driving us inward to the source of our quarrels: the passions at war within us. He presses the diagnosis further still, calling our friendship with the world adultery and naming our position before God as enmity. There is no softening here, no defense the reader can offer. The Law is given its full force.
And then, in the very middle of the passage, comes the pivot on which everything turns. But He gives more grace. Five short words that make every word that follows possible. Submit. Resist. Draw near. Cleanse. Purify. Mourn. Humble. None of these is a work we offer in order to earn grace. All of them are the shape of the life that grace creates: the honest reception of the One who gives more than we have lost. James does not ask us to climb back up to God. He shows us the God who has come down further than our enmity, with grace that is more.
The closing exhortation about judging follows directly from this. The one who has received mercy does not climb into the seat of the Judge. The one who knows his own desperate need for grace does not stand above his brother in judgment. There is one Lawgiver and Judge, James says, and we are not Him. Mercy received is mercy extended; mercy refused to others is mercy that has not yet been understood.
For the Lutheran Christian, this is the simul iustus et peccator made visible across a single passage. The Law strips away every illusion of our self-righteousness; the Gospel speaks the word of grace that is more. The Christian life is not increasing self-confidence in our own righteousness. It is increasing honesty about our need, met by increasing confidence in the grace that meets the need. We get better over time not because we become more impressive but because we become more honest, and the more honest we become, the more clearly we see the sufficiency of the Christ in whom alone our righteousness stands.
For Discussion
The following questions are for group discussion or personal reflection.
James traces congregational conflict to the passions at war within us. When you think of conflicts you have been part of (in your family, your workplace, or your church) can you see the internal desires that were driving you? Was the external conflict a symptom of something deeper?
James says we do not have because we do not ask, and that when we ask we often ask wrongly. In your own prayer life, are there things you have been trying to get or arrange in your own strength that you have never actually brought to God? Are there prayers you have offered that, honestly examined, were about your own passions rather than God’s will?
Friendship with the world is a strong phrase. What does it look like, concretely, in your own life? In what specific areas do you find yourself most drawn to the world’s values rather than Christ’s, in your work, your money, your relationships, your entertainment, your politics?
“But He gives more grace” is one of the most stunning sentences in the New Testament. How does this sentence function for you when you read it in context, after the severe diagnosis that precedes it? Does it land with the force James intends?
James’s sequence of verbs (submit, resist, draw near, cleanse, purify, mourn, humble) describes the posture of a Christian receiving grace. Which of these verbs is easiest for you? Which is most difficult? What does your answer reveal about your spiritual condition right now?
James closes the passage by warning against speaking evil of one another, because such speech places us in the seat of the Judge. When you find yourself tempted to judge a fellow Christian harshly, what would it look like to remember that you yourself stand under the same Law and live only by the same grace?
Looking Ahead
Next week we continue in chapter four and move into chapter five. The passage (4:13–5:12) covers what look at first like three different topics: planning our business lives without reference to God, the oppression of wealth that exploits workers, and the patience of the farmer who waits for the Lord’s coming. But the threads are connected. All three are about living rightly in the time before the Lord’s return. Read the passage carefully. The image of the farmer waiting for the early and late rains will speak especially to those of us who live among fields and harvests, and James’s sharp words about the rich deserve an honest hearing.
Closing Prayer
Merciful Father, we confess that our conflicts too often arise from the disordered desires of our own hearts, that we have been friends of the world when we should have been friends of You, and that we have judged our brothers and sisters when we ourselves stand only by Your mercy. We humble ourselves before You now. Grant us the grace that is greater than all our sin. Cleanse our hands, purify our hearts, and draw near to us as we draw near to You. Lift us up, not because we are worthy, but because You are good. And let us extend to others the same mercy that has been extended to us. Through Jesus Christ our Lord. Amen.